2002

• Frank Gotch - Pioneer Era
• Georg Hackenschmidt - Pioneer Era
• Ed "Strangler" Lewis - Pioneer Era
• Jim Londos - Pioneer Era
• Joe Stetcher - Pioneer Era
• Lou Thesz - Pioneer Era
• Gorgeous George - Television Era
• Buddy Rogers - Television Era
• Bruno Sammartino - Television Era
• Andre the Giant - Modern Era
• Ricky Steamboat - Modern Era
• Sky Low Low - Midget Wrestler
• Mildred Burke - Lady Wrestler

2003

• Martin "Farmer" Burns - Pioneer Era
• Stanislaus Zbyszko - Pioneer Era
• Killer Kowalski - Television Era
• Antonino Rocca - Television Era
• Nick Bockwinkel - Modern Era
• Hulk Hogan - Modern Era
• Little Beaver - Midget Wrestler
• Fabulous Moolah - Lady Wrestler
• Fabulous Kangaroos: Al Costello & Roy Heffernan - Tag Team
• Sam Muchnick - Non-Participant

2004

• William Muldoon - Pioneer Era
• Angelo Savoldi - Pioneer Era
• Fred Blassie - Television Era
• Verne Gagne - Television Era
• Terry Funk - Modern Era
• Harley Race - Modern Era
• Lord Littlebrook - Midget Wrestler
• Mae Young - Lady Wrestler
• The Vachons (Mad Dog & Butcher) - Tag Team
• Vince J. McMahon - Non-Participant
• Gordon Solie - Non-Participant

2005

• Orville Brown - Pioneer Era
• John Pesek - Pioneer Era
• Dick "The Destroyer" Beyer - Television Era
• Jack Brisco - Television Era
• Dory Funk Jr. - Modern Era
• George Steele - Modern Era
• Fuzzy Cupid - Midget Wrestler
• Penny Banner - Lady Wrestler
• The Crusher & The Bruiser - Tag Team
• Paul Boesch - Non-Participant

2006

• Ed Don George - Pioneer Era
• Bill Longson - Pioneer Era
• Don Leo Jonathan - Television Era
• Johnny Valentine - Television Era
• Ray Stevens - Modern Era
• Ric Flair - Modern Era
• Rikidozan - International
• June Byers - Lady Wrestler
• Ray Stevens & Pat Patterson - Tag Team
• Bobby Heenan - Non-Participant
• Ida May Martinez - Sen. Hugh Farley Award

2007

• Earl Caddock - Pioneer Era
• Gus Sonnenberg - Pioneer Era
• Danny Hodge - Television Era
• Pat O'Connor - Television Era
• Ted DiBiase - Modern Era
• Roddy Piper - Modern Era
• Karl Gotch - International
• Cora Combs - Lady Wrestler
• Chris Tolos & John Tolos - Tag Team
• Jack Pfefer - Non-Participant
• Bill Darnell - Sen. Hugh Farley Award

2008

• Ray Steele - Pioneer Era
• Tom Jenkins - Pioneer Era
• Bobo Brazil - Television Era
• Gene Kiniski - Television Era
• Bob Backlund - Modern Era
• Bret Hart - Modern Era
• Giant Baba - International
• Betty Niccoli - Lady Wrestler
• Ernie Dusek & Emil Dusek - Tag Team
• Joseph Raymond "Toots" Mondt - Non-Participant
• Tom Drake - Sen. Hugh Farley Award