Following the name of the champion(s): Indicates the number of times the wrestler has held that title at that point.
[...]
Indicates a gap in the listing where title changes are not known.
*
If used next to the names of the wrestlers, they may, in fact, not have held the title in the period indicated. If used next to the dates or places, either they are possibly wrong or the title changes are fictitious.
<
Title was held or changed hands no later than this. In these cases, it is known that a wrestler held the title at a certain time but not when he/she won it.
+
Broadcast date; the actual recording date is unknown.
@
Order uncertain. Different titleholders may be known for the same year, for example, but it is not known who held the title before whom.
#
Unofficial or disputable claims. These are usually matches that certainly took place, but where there is doubt that the wrestler shown should be recognized as a true title holder. These listings are also italicized in HTML files
Defeats Alex Shelley in tournament final; vacant in 04 when Sabin is injured.
James Keenan
2004-12-11
Wilmerding, PA
Wins 4-way match; vacant on 05-04-29.
John McChesney
2005-04-29
McKeesport, PA
Defeats Low-Ki in tournament final.
James Keenan
2005-08-20
Morristown, NJ
John McChesney [2]
2005-08-27
Pittsburgh, PA
Low-Ki
2006-03-18
Elizabeth, PA
Vacant on 06-04-15.
Delirious
2006-04-15
Elizabeth, PA
Defeats Troy Lords in tournament final.
John McChesney [3]
2006-11-11
Elizabeth, PA
Troy Lords
2007-01-19
Elizabeth, PA
Jason Gory
2007-05-11
McKeesport, PA
Vacant on 07-05-11.
Larry Sweeney
2007-05-11
McKeesport, PA
Defeats Shiima Xion in tournament final.
John McChesney [4]
2007-07-07
Elizabeth, PA
Larry Sweeney [2]
2008-01-19
Elizabeth, PA
Jerry Lynn
2008-05-17
Elizabeth, PA
Has won the Super Indy VII Tournament in on 08-04-25 but refuses the title until he can pin then-champion Sweeney.
Johnny Gargano
2008-10-11
Elizabeth, PA
Defeats Lynn and Super Hentai in a 3-way match; vacant in 08 due to injury.
Delirious
2008-10-26
Cheswick, PA
Defeats Jason Gory, Super Hentai, and Larry Sweeney in a 4-way match.
Super Hentai
2009-05-16
White Oak, PA
Defeats Justin Idol in tournament final.
Shiima Xion
2010-05-08
Elizabeth, PA
Defeats Johnny Gargano and Azrieal in tournament 3-way final.
Super Hentai [2]
2011-01-29
Elizabeth, PA
Matt Justice
2011-03-19
Elizabeth, PA
Defeats Hentai and Shiima Xion in a 3-way match.
Super Hentai [3]
2011-04-16
Franklin, PA
Egotistico Fantastico
2011-06-18
Elizabeth, PA
Defeats Hentai and El Generico in tournament 3-way final; vacant in 11.
Façade
2011-12-10
Elizabeth, PA
Defeats Logan Shulo, Hallowicked, and Matt Cross in a 4-way match.
Sami Callihan
2012-06-23
Elizabeth, PA
Façade [2]
2012-10-20
Elizabeth, PA
Defeats Callihan and Rich Swann in 3-way match; vacant in 12-12 due to injury.
Logan Shulo
2012-12-15
Elizabeth, PA
Reigning World Heavyweight champion, defeats Sami Callihan for the vacant Super Indy Title; loses the World Title later on the same card.
Anthony Nese
2013-01-26
Elizabeth, PA
Façade [3]
2013-06-15
Elizabeth, PA
Defeats Nese in tournament final.
Shiima Xion
2013-10-19
Elizabeth, PA
R.J. City
2013-12-14
Elizabeth, PA
Andrew Palace
2014-10-18
Elizabeth, PA
Dylan Bostic
2015-06-13
Elizabeth, PA
Defeats Palace in a tournament semi-final and Alex Daniels and Raymond Rowe in 3-way final.
Andrew Palace [2]
2015-12-12
Elizabeth, PA
Vacates on 16-06-11 for the Super Indy tournament.
Josh Alexander
2016-06-11
Elizabeth, PA
Defeats Jonathan Gresham in the Super Indy tournament final; Palace has lost to Gresham in semi-final; vacant on 16-10-11 when Alexander cannot make the scheduled title defense.
Chris LeRusso
2016-10-15
Elizabeth, PA
Defeats Facade.
John McChesney [5]
2017-04-08
Meadville, PA
Chris LeRusso [2]
2017-05-13
Elizabeth, PA
Adam Cole
2017-06-10
Elizabeth, PA
John McChesney [6]
2017-07-22
Elizabeth, PA
Gory (Jason Gory) [2]
2017-08-19
Elizabeth, PA
David Starr
2018-06-09
Elizabeth, PA
Jonathan Gresham
2018-06-09
Elizabeth, PA
John McChesney [7]
2019-01-19
Elizabeth, PA
Wardlow
2019-03-16
Elizabeth, PA
Josh Alexander [2]
2019-08-10
Elizabeth, PA
Johnny Patch
2019-10-05
Elizabeth, PA
Sam Adonis
2020-09-12
Washington, PA
Defeats Patch in the 1st round of the Super Indy 19 tournament.
Brian Pillman Jr.
2020-09-12
Washington, PA
Defeats Adonis in the semi-final and Lee Moriarty in the final of the Super Indy 19 tournament.
Bill Collier
2021-02-20
Elizabeth, PA
Matthew Justice [2]
2021-07-17
Elizabeth, PA
Bill Collier [2]
2021-08-15
Elizabeth, PA
Vacant on 21-10-16 when Collier loses to Anthony Greene in the semi-final of "Super Indy 20" tournament.
Cole Carter
2021-10-16
Elizabeth, PA
Defeats Anthony Greene in the final of "Super Indy 20" tournament; vacates in 22-01 upon signing with WWE.
Derek Dillinger
2022-01-22
Elizabeth, PA
Defeats Anthony Young, Andrew Palace, and Jaxon Argos in a 4-way match.
Cole Carter [2]
2022-10-08
Elizabeth, PA
Defeats Dillinger in the final of "Super Indy 21" tournament.
Jock Samson
2023-06-03
Elizabeth, PA
Vacant on 23-10-07 when Samson loses to Anthony Catena in the quater final of "Super Indy 22".
Duke Davis
2023-10-07
Elizabeth, PA
Defeats Anthony Catena in the final of "Super Indy 22" tournament.
Ganon Jones Jr.
2023-11-04
Elizabeth, PA
Anthony Catena
2023-11-04
Elizabeth, PA
Ganon Jones Jr. [2]
2023-12-02
Elizabeth, PA
Vacant on 24-10-05 when Jones loses to Zach Nystrom in the semi-final of "Super Indy 23".
Sam Holloway
2024-10-05
Elizabeth, PA
Defeats Zach Nystrom in the final of "Super Indy 23" tournament.
